How To Spot A Real Hermès Scarf
It’s not every day you come across a wearable masterpiece. And when it comes to Hermès, it’s their literal business to combine expert craftsmanship with the highest caliber of artistry. And no item encapsulates this marriage of form and function more than the iconic Hermès scarf.
Based on a woodblock drawing by Hermès family member Robert Dumas, the scarf made its first appearance in 1937—the original motif was titled “Jeu des Omnibus et Dames Blanches,” and drew inspiration from a French board game.
All Hermès scarves are produced in Lyon, France, but this signature piece is an international effort—the luxury maison hires people from across the globe to create their designs. Past artists have included Rei Kawakubo, a postmaster in Texas, a children’s book illustrator, and many more.
Discerning an authentic Hermès scarf from a counterfeit requires an understanding of the intricate details that define its creation—and an appreciation for the heritage that distinguishes Hermès from the rest.
A Glimpse into Heritage and Creation
To truly appreciate the allure of an Hermès scarf, let’s dive into its history and creation process.
Introduced in 1937, the Hermès scarf’s creative journey begins with a woodblock drawing, often inspired by the talented members of the Hermès family. This initial sketch serves as the blueprint for a design that will ultimately end up as a 100% silk scarf.
What also sets Hermès apart is its commitment to a global creative collaboration. The France-based atelier serves as a melting pot of cultures, with artisans from around the world lending their expertise to the creation of these scarves, which ultimately results in a tapestry of designs that capture the essence of different cultures and perspectives.
Like with any luxury item, the creation of an Hermès scarf is an art that demands time, precision, and dedication. The process unfolds over a span of 18 months—from the conception of the design to the final product. A considerable portion of this timeline is dedicated to selecting the perfect color palette, a task that takes six months to complete. Engravers, on the other hand, invest an average of 750 hours in perfecting the screens that bring the design to life. This meticulous attention to detail ensures that every Hermès scarf is a harmonious marriage of artistry and craftsmanship.
The Challenge of Counterfeit Hermès Scarves
Of course, the allure of owning a piece of “luxury” at a fraction of the cost has led to a proliferation of fakes on the market—and, like with every luxury creation, these counterfeits are pretty much unavoidable.
The quest for authenticity becomes an endeavor of its own, demanding an acute understanding of the subtle nuances that distinguish the real from the imitation. (That’s what we’re here to help with, of course.)
Unfortunately, counterfeiters have become increasingly skilled at replicating the appearance of genuine Hermès scarves, making the authentication process even more crucial. Educating oneself about the craftsmanship and details unique to authentic Hermès scarves becomes a valuable tool in preserving the legacy of this timeless accessory.
The Craftsmanship That Sets Hermès Apart
The hallmark of a genuine Hermès scarf lies in its construction. Available in various sizes—70 x 70 cm, 90 x 90 cm, 45 x 45 cm, and 120 x 120 cm—these scarves exhibit rolled edges meticulously created by artisans specializing solely in scarf production. This labor-intensive process ensures that each edge is perfectly aligned and matched, resulting in a work of art that’s also a feat of engineering. The dedication to perfection is such that an artisan might roll the edges of only seven scarves in a single day. If a scarf displays machine-stitched edges, overlock stitching, or any deviation from the hand-rolled standard, it’s an immediate indication of its counterfeit nature.
“Each scarf has hand-rolled edges,” says Hajleigh Nebeker, Valuation Manager at TRR. “It’s an expensive process that’s hard to fake on counterfeit examples. Stitching also shouldn’t be perfect, since it’s also completed by hand.”
Material Elegance and its Authentication
Quality materials are the foundation of Hermès’ reputation for luxury, and the Hermès scarf is no exception. The brand’s proprietary silk, twice the weight of typical silks, exemplifies the brand’s commitment to excellence. These scarves are woven in a tight twill pattern, a choice that not only preserves their shape but also allows for graceful draping and styling without compromising the square silhouette. The tactile experience is paramount —gently pull the fabric from side to side, and it should effortlessly spring back to its original form, devoid of any stretching or distortion.
The fabric tag, an integral element of the scarf, is sewn onto the corner and reads “Made In France.” This tag, crafted from 100% silk (or soie, as it’s known in French), signifies authenticity.
“Hermès produces its own silk, which is one of the reasons the quality is so luxurious,” says Nebeker. “Counterfeit examples rarely exhibit the thick twill and vibrancy that authentic ones have.”
However, the absence of this tag doesn’t unequivocally indicate a counterfeit. Counterfeiters often remove these tags, necessitating a deeper dive into other markers of authenticity. As tag designs may evolve, scrutinizing attributes such as size, color, stitching quality, and labeling becomes crucial in the authentication process.
Decoding the Scarf’s Identity
Beyond craftsmanship and materials, an Hermès scarf’s authenticity is embedded in its unique identifiers. Artist signatures discreetly positioned in the corner and the integration of the scarf’s title into the design itself are hallmarks of an authentic Hermès scarf. Although the title might be artfully concealed, contemporary designs invariably feature it as an integral design element. In addition, the presence of the Hermès name alongside a copyright symbol subtly reinforces authenticity, often etched in an inconspicuous yet consistent manner across contemporary scarves.
“Each scarf is screen-printed by hand,” says Nebeker. The process of screen-printing each scarf is meticulous, with individual screens dedicated to each color. Designs might encompass an impressive array of up to 32 colors, meticulously refined over months of testing to achieve a harmonious palette. Hermès’ commitment to perfection is unwavering—they destroy any scarves with deviations, such as unintentional negative spaces or accidental overlaps in the coloring process. These are red flags if you’re trying to determine a scarf’s authenticity.
The Final Touch of Packaging
Authenticity transcends the scarf itself and extends to its packaging. While plastic sleeves were once used during the 1980s, contemporary Hermès scarves are presented in the brand’s signature orange boxes. The authenticity of the packaging lies in its subtle nuances. An authentic box exudes a refined texture with a delicate eggshell sheen. The central placement of Hermès’ iconic horse-drawn carriage logo, accompanied by “Hermès / Paris,” is a testament to the brand’s legacy. Counterfeit boxes often lack these attributes, appearing glossy and lightweight. It’s essential to note that an authenticity card accompanying a scarf is a clear sign of inauthenticity, as Hermès scarves do not come with such cards.
Authentic Hermès Scarves
When it comes to authentic Hermès scarves, remember that you’re not just investing in an accessory; you’re acquiring a piece of art. Our carefully authenticated selection of Hermès scarves is here for the shopping—without the worry of knowing whether you’re purchasing a counterfeit. (Again, our authentication process is rigorous.)
Whether draped over your shoulders or tied around the handle of your favorite Hermès bag, an Hermès scarf is more than an accessory—it’s an homage to a tradition of heritage and craftsmanship.
Invest in your own wearable piece of art and shop our selection of Hermès scarves.
All items are pre-owned and consigned to The RealReal. Trademarks are owned by their respective brand owners. No brand owner endorses or sponsors this ad or has any association and/or affiliation with The RealReal.
Please note: Brand standards, logos and other identifying features may have changed since the time of publication.
